Build Cheap Home Server
Read on to learn how we decided between Intel and AMD builds (spoiler: we built both), how to set up Windows Home Server, and what third-party programs to add to leverage the power of a dedicated server.
The Performance Test: AMD vs Intel
When we started building our home server, we knew we wanted a price around $500, but we weren't sure what CPU architecture to use. Our budget limited us to around $100 for CPU, which meant we could choose between a dual-core Intel Core i3 530 ($115) or a quad-core AMD Athlon II X4 630 ($99). The problem? We wanted to be able to do light video transcoding and file container repackaging on the server. Our previous experience with lightweight, NAS-style Windows Home Server machines made us skeptical that dual-core machines would have the CPU juice needed to handle any transcodes, much less transcoding HD resolution source material.
Windows File Transfer Test
Using Windows default file browser to transfer our test files, we saw a fairly clear performance victory from the AMD machine in every test other than the large file download. No matter what we did, the AMD system just choked on the 4GB file, it took almost 30 seconds longer to download the file from the AMD server than it did from the Intel one. The Athlon-equipped server handled the smaller files better than the Intel server, turning in the only single-digit transfer time we saw.| Windows File Sharing | Athlon II X4 630 | Core i3 530 |
|---|---|---|
| Large File Download (sec) | 76.7 | 48.2 |
| Large File Upload (sec) | 49.1 | 54.2 |
| Small Files Download (sec) | 8.7 | 16.8 |
| Small Files Upload (sec) | 41.5 | 41.8 |
FTP Test
Our FTP test showed different results. The AMD machine took two tests, the Intel machine took two tests. While most of the scores were close, the small files upload was dominated by the Intel machine. We're not sure why the discrepancy, but as with the Windows file transfer test, it's not a big enough problem to knock either machine.| FTP File Transfer | Athlon II X4 630 | Core i3 530 |
|---|---|---|
| Large File Download (sec) | 51.7 | 50.9 |
| Large File Upload (sec) | 51 | 53.12 |
| Small Files Download (sec) | 14.2 | 16.6 |
| Small Files Upload (sec) | 81.23 | 61.82 |
Power
Power turned out to be the big differentiating factor on our Home Servers. While the dual-core Intel machine drew a meager 49W at idle and 70W under load, the quad-core Athlon was a juice guzzler in comparison--pulling 71W at idle and 90W under load. While it's true that it's a little unfair to compare power use between a dual-core and quad core, the performance (in video transcoding and network transfers) and price are close enough that we're comfortable making the comparison. And, the fact that the Intel machine was fast enough to do what we wanted while pulling less power was enough to make it the winner of our Windows Home Server test.| Power Usage | Athlon II X4 630 | Core i3 530 |
|---|---|---|
| Idle (W) | 71 | 49 |
| Load (W) | 90 | 70 |
The Complete Parts List
| Category | Part | Price* |
|---|---|---|
| CPU | Intel Core i3-530 | $115 |
| Motherboard | Gigabyte GA-H55M-S2H | $88 |
| Case | Cooler Master Elite 310 ATX | $40 |
| Primary Hard Drive | Seagate Barracuda 1TB 7200rpm | $84 |
| Operating System | Windows Home Server OEM | $100 |
| Memory | Crucial DDR3 4GB kit | $112 |
| Power Supply | Antec 500W | $50 |
| Additional Hard Drives (optional) | Western Digital Caviar Green 2TB | $136 |
| TOTAL: | $725 ($580 w/ 1 drive) |
Setting Up Windows Home Server
Once you've build your server, it's time to get Windows Home Server installed. Without this OS, there's really nothing different between the server and any desktop PC. In fact, that's why you can easily repurpose an old desktop as a home server just by installing WHS. The install process is fairly straight forward, but we'll walk you through the important steps and offer some pro tips.
Install from a USB key
Depending on how you obtained Windows Home Server (either by buying an OEM DVD or downloading the trial version), your install process may differ a bit. For our purposes, we're using the downloaded trial ISO, which we've then mounted on a hard drive using Slysoft's freeware Virtual CloneDrive utility. The reason we've done this is because, well, our Home Server doesn't actually have a DVD-Rom drive! It doesn't need one, either, because we're going to install the OS using a USB key. The web ISO is also more up-to-date than currently shipping OEM DVDs, so you can avoid having to install as many OS updates.
Configure your motherboard BIOS to boot from the USB key to start the WHS installation process. The install wizard will ask for you to input some basic preferences, such as the server name and a strong administrator password. It'll also show you what hard drives it's detected in your machine, so make sure both drives are present. When prompted to choose a primary drive for the OS, select your fastest hard drive. In our case, that's the Seagate 1TB drive. WHS will format all installed drives and configure them with its unique filestructure. When setup is finished, the server will restart and be ready for use. The OS will resemble the Windows you're familiar with, complete with the Desktop and Start Menu. Head into the Control Panel and finish installing any missing drivers to get the server network-capable.
Add and manage clients
Download and install the Connector software on every machine you want your WHS to back up (up to 10). When installed properly, the Connector should appear in your Windows system tray. This is where you'll be manually start backups, access network shares, and load the Windows Home Server Console to manage backups, add users, monitor storage, change server settings, and install Add-ins.
Set Up Remote Access
Once WHS verifies that your Server can be accessed from the web, you can set up a homeserver.com subdomain. Click the Configure button under Domain Name and run through the setup wizard. WHS will require that you have a Windows Live account to use this feature--this is the same as your Xbox Live login. Once you approve Microsoft's terms and conditions, you can choose any homeserver.com subdomain that is still available. If everything is done right, you'll be able to access your server's files using this address.
Backing up a Mac
Additional software and services
Windows Home Server supports Add-Ins, which are third-party extensions that enhance the functionality of the server from within the console software. We list our six favorites here. But while Add-Ins are useful for maintenance and administrative tasks, power users will want to install additional server software to make the most out of the machine's multi-core processor and generous stock of memory. Since WHS can run Windows software, this is a breeze. The only thing you should keep in mind is that these programs should be installed as Windows Services, so they automatically load up without any user logging onto the machine. To install these programs, you'll need to move the files over using network shares and log into your Server using Windows' Remote Desktop utility.PS3 Media Server
Air Video
Getting video to a networked game console is one thing, but streaming wirelessly to an iPhone or iPad requires another server service. Fortunately, there's an app for that. Air Video ($3) is an iPhone and iPad app that can play video streamed to it from a desktop or server software counterpart. Getting Air Video running on WHS requires configuring it as a service, and we show you how here.
Even though you can use Remote Desktop or Remote Access to log into your Windows Home Server to transfer files, using an FTP server is far more efficient and versatile. Using FTP, you get built-in error checking for file transfers, queue transfers, and create user accounts to share with your friends and associates. WHS's unique filesystem makes setting up an FTP server more than just downloading and running an executable, so we'll show you what you need to do to get a FTP server running on your Windows Home Server.
Microsoft SyncToy
And that's it! In a Home Server, your data and media files are more secure, versatile, and accessible. With disk storage prices at all time lows (2TB for approaching $100!), you'd be foolish not to run a server, if only for backup. And if you're already running a server at home, share your experiences in the comments below!
